The HR Gap: Too Big to Wing It?

There’s a slightly awkward stage that many growing businesses eventually reach.  You’ve got too many people for HR to be something someone squeezes in between payroll, ordering stationery and organising the Christmas party.  But you’re not quite at the point where employing a full-time HR Manager or Head of People makes sense either. 

Welcome to the HR gap! 

It’s a very normal stage of growth. But it’s also one where people problems can start becoming business problems surprisingly quickly. 

When Winging It Stops Working 

In the early days of a business, people management tends to be pretty informal.  The owner hires people. Someone finds an employment agreement. Your Office Manager keeps track of leave. Managers deal with issues as they crop up and everyone generally knows what’s going on because there aren’t that many of you. 

And for a while, that can work perfectly well. 

Then the business grows.  Suddenly you have more managers, more personalities, more employment documentation, more performance conversations, more expectations and, inevitably, more complicated people situations.  The processes that worked beautifully with five people start creaking a little at twelve.  It doesn’t necessarily mean anything has gone wrong. It often just means the business has grown up. 

Spot the Warning Signs 

So, how do you know you’re reaching the HR gap? 

Sometimes the signs are obvious. You’re spending increasing amounts of time dealing with people issues, managers are asking questions you’re not quite sure how to answer, or you’ve realised your employment agreements haven’t been looked at since everyone was obsessed with Tiger King! 

Other signs are easier to miss. 

Different managers start handling similar situations differently. Performance issues linger because nobody quite knows how to tackle them. Recruitment becomes reactive. Your structure has evolved organically rather than intentionally. Your Office Manager has somehow become the unofficial HR department despite HR never actually being part of their job!

And perhaps the biggest clue is that most of your HR activity is happening in response to something.  Someone resigns. Someone complains. Someone isn’t performing. Someone wants flexible working. Someone needs managing. 

Cue HR.  Good people management should involve much more than putting out fires. 

Less Firefighting, More Forward Thinking 

As businesses grow, the HR conversation needs to change. 

Instead of only asking, “How do we deal with this issue?”, you can start asking: 

  • Where are our people risks? 
  • Do our structure and roles still make sense? 
  • What kind of culture are we creating? 
  • Who are our future leaders? 
  • What do we need to put in place now to support the next stage of growth? 

Those are business questions as much as they are HR questions.  And ideally, you’re asking them before there’s a problem. 

Do You Really Need an HR Manager? 

Maybe. But not necessarily.  One of the biggest changes we’ve seen in the way SMEs access expertise is that businesses no longer need to employ every capability they need full-time.  Finance has been doing this for years with fractional CFOs and outsourced finance teams. Marketing does it. IT does it.  HR can work the same way. 

What matters is working out what level of support your business actually needs.  For some businesses, it’s having ongoing access to an HR expert who knows the business and can answer questions, review documents, support managers and help deal with employee relations issues as they arise. 

For others, the need has moved beyond HR support into genuine People capability. Someone who becomes part of the rhythm of the business, attends leadership meetings, coaches, manages, helps shape the people strategy, builds systems and thinks ahead about structure, capability and culture. 

And some businesses simply need specialist help every now and then.  None of those options is inherently better than another.  The right answer depends on where your business is now and where it’s going next. 

Your Office Manager Will Thank You! 

We should also spare a thought for the Office Managers, Operations Managers, Finance Managers and Executive Assistants who mysteriously acquire HR along the way. 

Often, they are extremely capable people. Which is exactly how they ended up with it.  But asking someone to coordinate employment paperwork or onboarding is very different from expecting them to navigate employment relations, coach managers through difficult conversations, interpret employment obligations or develop your people strategy. 

There comes a point where giving them proper HR support isn’t taking responsibility away from them.  It’s giving them backup.  And possibly removing several tabs permanently open in their browser! 

Your Business Grows. HR Should Too. 

There isn’t a magic headcount where suddenly you “need HR”. 

A 10-person professional services business may have very different needs from a 40-person operational business. Growth plans, management capability, complexity, risk and culture all play a part.   

A better question is:  Does the way we currently manage our people still fit the business we have become?  If the answer is “not really”, that’s worth paying attention to.  Because the best time to strengthen your people foundations isn’t when you’re knee-deep in a restructure, performance issue or employment dispute.  It’s while things are going well. 

That’s when you have the space to build the systems, manager capability and people practices that will help keep them going well. 

Mind the HR Gap 

Growing out of DIY HR is a good problem to have. It means the business is evolving.  The trick is recognising when what got you here won’t necessarily get you through the next stage. 

You might need occasional expertise. You might need regular HR support. Or you might be ready for a fractional People Partner who works alongside your leadership team and helps drive the people side of the business.  And the best part? You can get the expertise you need without committing to a full-time HR role. 

At Spice, we work with growing businesses in all those ways, adding as little or as much HR capability as makes sense for where you are right now.  Because your HR should fit your business, not the other way around. 

Ready to bridge the HR gap? 

Just Add Spice. 

Because “We Should Do More Training” Isn’t a Strategy!

Training is one of those things that always sounds like a good idea. It sits comfortably on strategy decks, appears in engagement surveys, and regularly makes the wish list for “when things calm down a bit”.

In reality, things rarely calm down.

In busy SMEs, training often gets squeezed between client deadlines, operational pressure, and the day-to-day reality of keeping the business moving. When learning does happen, it is often rushed, generic, or disconnected from the work people are actually doing. A workshop is delivered, everyone nods politely, and a few weeks later it is business as usual.

The problem is not that people do not want to learn. It is that learning has not been designed to survive the pace of a SME.

Training that sticks looks very different. It is practical, targeted, and woven into how work gets done. It supports the capability the business needs now and builds toward what it will need next. When learning is designed this way, it stops feeling like an extra and starts pulling its weight.

Make Learning Real, Not Theoretical

This is usually the point where well-meaning training starts to unravel. Courses are selected because they are available, familiar, or sound broadly useful, rather than because they solve a specific problem the business is facing.

When learning is designed in isolation from the work, it struggles to compete with real deadlines and real pressure. Generic content, off-the-shelf programmes, and one-size-fits-all workshops rarely translate into changed behaviour, not because the material is poor, but because it lacks context.

Learning sticks when it is clearly tied to real work, real expectations, and real outcomes. That is when training stops feeling theoretical and starts being useful.

Use Individual Development Plans To Focus Effort

Another common challenge in SMEs is scattergun development. People are sent on courses because they sound useful, not because they align to a clear plan.

Individual Development Plans help bring focus. A good IDP connects business priorities, role expectations, and individual strengths and gaps. It answers simple but powerful questions. What capability does this role need now, what capability will it need next, and what support will help this person grow into that.

When learning is anchored to an IDP, it feels purposeful rather than optional. Leaders know what they are developing. Employees know why it matters. Progress becomes visible.

IDPs also help prevent development overload. Not everything needs fixing at once. Prioritisation is part of making learning stick.

Build Capability, Not Just Confidence

Soft skills training is often undervalued in technical or operational environments, yet it is frequently where performance issues actually sit. Communication, decision-making, influence, and leadership capability shape how effectively technical skills are used.

In-House and Bespoke Soft Skills Workshops are most effective when they are contextualised to the organisation and delivered in a way that feels relevant, not fluffy. That means using real scenarios, real challenges, and real expectations.

We often remind clients that confidence without capability is risky, and capability without confidence is wasted. Well-designed workshops build both, giving people practical tools they can use immediately.

Make Skills Visible With a Skills Matrix

Many SMEs rely heavily on a handful of key people, often without realising the risk. When knowledge isn’t documented, gaps only show up when someone leaves or is suddenly unavailable.

A Skills Matrix is one of the simplest and most effective tools for making capability visible. It shows who can do what, where there is depth, and where there is risk.

From there, training becomes strategic rather than reactive. Development can be targeted to reduce risk, build resilience, and support growth. It also helps employees see development pathways, which supports engagement and retention.

Skills matrices turn learning into a business tool, not just an HR initiative.

Plan For The Future, Not Just Today

Succession planning often feels like something only large organisations need. In reality, SMEs are often more vulnerable to disruption when key people move on.

Strategic succession planning does not mean naming successors and hoping for the best. It means identifying critical roles, understanding what capability they require, and deliberately developing people over time.

Training, IDPs, skills matrices, and leadership development all feed into effective succession planning. When these elements are connected, learning stops being ad hoc and starts supporting long-term sustainability.

From an HR consultancy lens, succession planning is not about predicting the future perfectly. It is about reducing risk and creating options.

Keep Learning Light, Practical, and Ongoing

One of the biggest myths about training is that it has to be time-consuming to be effective. In reality, learning sticks best when it is broken into manageable pieces and reinforced over time.

Short workshops, practical tools, real-world application, and follow-up conversations all help embed learning. Leaders play a critical role here. When managers reinforce learning through coaching and feedback, capability grows faster.

New Zealand research consistently shows that employees who feel supported in their development are more engaged and more likely to stay. MBIE and WorkSafe guidance both highlight capability building as a contributor to productivity, wellbeing, and safer work practices.

Training that sticks is not about one big moment. It is about consistent reinforcement.

Training should work as hard as your people do.

In a busy SME, training cannot be a distraction from the work. It needs to support the work.

When learning is tailored, aligned to clear development plans, supported by visible capability mapping, and connected to succession thinking, it becomes part of how the business grows. Not an add-on. Not a nice-to-have.

That is when training actually works.

Time to Add Spice

At Spice, we design training that fits the realities of SMEs. From tailored Training and Development Programmes and Individual Development Plans, to In-House and Bespoke Soft Skills Workshops, Skills Matrices, and Succession Planning, we help businesses build capability that lasts.

If your training feels busy but not effective, it might be time for a different approach.

Add Spice.